Welcome to Humphreys Restaurant
Nestled on scenic Shelter Island in San Diego, Humphreys Restaurant embodies the essence of New American cuisine with a seafood focus that delights the senses. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and exceptional service, it caters to diverse tastes, offering everything from abundant vegetarian options to fresh, catch-of-the-day dishes. Guests can savor brunch or dinner while enjoying the picturesque outdoor seating or the lively buzz indoors. With a full bar and catering services, Humphreys is perfect for gatherings, whether it's a casual outing or a special celebration. Here, every dish is crafted with care, promising a memorable dining experience.
- 2241 Shelter Island Dr San Diego, CA 92106 United States Hotline: (619) 224-3577
Welcome to Humphreys Restaurant: A Culinary Gem on Shelter Island
Located at 2241 Shelter Island Dr, San Diego, CA, Humphreys Restaurant stands as a beacon for food lovers seeking an unforgettable dining experience. Celebrated for its New American seafood cuisine, this upmarket establishment effortlessly pairs artistry with sustainability to serve a tantalizing array of dishes that tantalize the palate.
Why Choose Humphreys?
- Reservations and Accessibility: Whether you're planning a special occasion or a casual dinner, Humphreys welcomes guests with open arms. The restaurant takes reservations and offers takeout and delivery options, ensuring a seamless experience.
- Vegetarian and Kid-Friendly Options: With many vegetarian choices available, there's something for everyone. The kid-friendly setting makes it an ideal choice for family outings.
- Ambiance: The moderate noise level combined with the possibility of outdoor seating creates a comfortable atmosphere perfect for brunch or dinner. For those who enjoy al fresco dining, the outdoor patio is a lovely option.
- Full Bar and Amenities: Sip on craft cocktails or choose from an extensive wine list at the full bar. Additional utilities include free Wi-Fi, catering services, and facilities for groups.
- Dog-Friendly: Don’t want to leave your furry friend at home? Humphreys is pet-friendly, allowing you to share the experience with your dog.
Diving into the Menu
Humphreys Restaurant showcases a menu that is both innovative and rooted in comfort, featuring an array of seafood dishes that highlight fresh, local ingredients. Each plate is a delightful celebration of flavor, beautifully presented, and well thought out. From succulent fish tacos to rich, creamy risottos, every bite tells a story. One can almost hear the waves lapping at the nearby shores as you savor a perfectly grilled catch with zestful garnishes.
On my recent visit, I couldn't resist trying their signature dish, the Grilled Salmon with Citrus Salsa. The fish was cooked to perfection—flaky and rich with a bright, zesty salsa that danced on my taste buds. It was a true testament to Humphreys’ commitment to quality and creativity in their culinary offerings.
For a dining experience that captures the essence of coastal Californian cuisine, look no further than Humphreys Restaurant. Whether you're in the mood for a peaceful brunch, a vibrant dinner, or simply want to enjoy fresh seafood with good company, Humphreys is ready to serve your cravings.
To make a reservation or inquire about catering options, call (619) 224-3577. You might just discover your new favorite dining spot on Shelter Island!

This place is lovely! The food was fantastic baked chicken for me, filet mignon for the hubby. Do yourself a favor, and get a Mai Tai it is an old family recipe and truly the best Ive ever had. Service was amazing, shout out to Jolene who was a delight! Definitely worth a visit.

What a BLAST!!! My husband and I were visiting from out of town and this place happened to be right next door to our hotel we heard the souljazz music from the hot tub and had to go check out what was happening next door. We ate a great dinner and I had the most fun watching the live band on Saturday and dancing!

I have to give the most kudos to the servers Carlos, Jake, and Miguel. They are the kindest servers and so attentive. I stayed here 4 days and had breakfast everyday here and dinnerlunch 4 days. The truffle fries are amazing. ...

Booked for a birthday celebration. Just the 2 of us, from the U.K. The receptionist was very personable and greeted us by name and wished me a Happy Birthday. Seated in the window with a beautiful sunset view over the marina. Very attentive ...

We are here at Humphreys restaurant getting something to eat before we attend a ZZ Top concert at Humphreys by the Bay! The restaurant is very nice and has a great View on the bay! Has great atmosphere and the service was very good and the ...

4.5 This restaurant was awesome. Our server was amazing, and our food was even better. I got shrimp .... pasta. I dont remember exactly what I got and I forgot to ...

Christmas day brunch was great! Good food selection, two free mimosas per adult, plenty of variety.

What a great overall experience. A first time taking in dinner a show at the Famous Humphreys. Drinks in the lounge before dinner perfect! For dinner, my wife had the lobster, I had the steak perfect! Then on to see Home Free a ...